Project Frankenmill – Part 20, Choose Wisely

I mainly considered two approaches to mounting rails to the column.

Approach 1 – add some kind of additional side supports to the existing column and mount the rails to the supports. A simple plate would be all that’s needed to mount the head to the blocks.

Approach 1

Approach 2 – mount the rails directly to the column and build a more complex saddle assembly to attach the head to the blocks. This appeared to use less material overall, but ultimately the headache of aligning the linear rails in this orientation steered me away from it.

Approach 2

I spent some time debating using steel vs aluminum for the added supports. After searching for drops from metal vendors, I ultimately settled on using 2024 aluminum rather than 1018 steel. Some compromises here obviously – aluminum has a significantly different coefficient of expansion than the cast iron, for one. And it’s not as easy to do traditional scraping to dial in the rail mounting surfaces in aluminum vs steel. But availability, weight, shipping/transport cost, and ease of cutting and machining all won out for me. I figure that it’s a low precision hobby machine – and all of the other conversion parts are already made out of aluminum. Any thermal expansion problems I create are likely to be overshadowed by all of the other issues the machine will continue to have even after fixing the Z axis.

Based on what materials were readily available as drops from the metal yard, I ended up going with significantly larger dimension material for the side supports than the initial sketch above – settling on 1.5″ x 2.5″ bar stock.

A rough draft of the chosen approach.

This approach might add some rigidity to the upper part of the column (especially if I can partially close in the front side) – but it’s limited by the weak bottom section where I needed to allow room for the original bolts to attach to the base. I have some things I’d like to explore that might help with rigidity in that area – basically some stiffening plates that would mount on the back of the new column, and potentially attach to the base at some newly created mounting points.

Related Posts

Project Frankenmill – Part 33, Claustrophobia

Final positions for the DIN rails and wire management have been nailed down. It’s much more tight than one should really wire a panel like this, but…

Project Frankenmill – Part 32, You’re Gonna Need a Bigger Boat

It seems to be a rule that no matter what size electronics enclosure you have, you will always have at least 10% more stuff that you need…

Project Frankenmill – Part 31, Full Pull

While I still haven’t gotten into the detail of squaring and tramming, I’ve been intensely curious to see if the new Z axis would be happier with…

Project Frankenmill – Alpha and Omega

Since 2009, I’ve been messing around with CNC machines. I started out with a small manual milling machine from Grizzly, and converted it to CNC using a…

Project Frankenmill – Part 30, Do You Even Lift Bro?

Hauled the column back down to the shop and mounted it back on the machine. Sure is a lot heavier than it used to be! Muscling things…

Project Frankenmill – Part 29, More Machining and Motion

Had some productive time in the shop during the holiday. First step was to make the counterbores for the M6 cap screws a bit deeper. Easy to…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *